I first came to Sugar Island in May 1990, when I was nine years old. My father was a teacher, a Jersey Shore charter captain, and an avid angler who always heard the Thousand Islands was the area’s best-kept secret. When lifelong member Bill Banholzer invited us to help scout a tent platform site, my dad, Bill, his son Brian, and I headed up.
Approaching an unfamiliar island in an unknown body of water initially terrified me, but the moment we set up camp, it felt like heaven and I belonged there. While our fathers staked out a rocky plot for the platform, Brian and I explored every inch of the island. That single long weekend turned into a 36-year long tradition. For over three decades, our family spent two weeks every summer on Sugar—my father fishing, my mother enjoying the serene nature, and my sister and I paddling and swimming the crystal clear St. Lawrence.
The memories made on Sugar are my most prized possessions. My relationship with the island has spanned a lifetime, evolving from paddling adventures with Marlyn Vogel and Chuck Sutherland to serving as Trustee and Chairman. Sugar Island will always hold a sacred place in my heart, and I still count the days until I can return to the island.
About the Author
John Nowicky is the Chair of the Sugar Island Board of Trustees. He first visited Sugar Island at age nine, and for more than three decades his family spent two weeks there every summer. Sugar Island is a 35-acre, rustic island in the heart of the Thousand Islands near Gananoque, Ontario, owned by the ACA and open to all members year round. Learn more and plan your visit at https://americancanoe.org/community/properties/sugar-island/.
This story is published as part of the 2026 ACA Story Project, a month-long collection of stories written by ACA members. Without opportunity, these stories wouldn’t exist. That’s what the ACA does. Through education, stewardship, competition, and club support, we create opportunities for paddlers of all abilities. Your gift helps write the next chapter. Help us raise $25,000 by December 1 for the next paddler, and the one after that.
